Inisiatif Malaysia Bebas Asap Rokok

Tuesday, November 02, 2004

Tamu Selasa: Bijak memilih kunci hak kepenggunaan

Berita Harian 2hb November 2004
Rencana & Pendapat


SETIAP kali tiba musim perayaan, pasti timbul masalah kenaikan harga barang. Justeru, sikap keterbukaan pengguna dalam menerima maklumat, berbincang dan bertukar pandangan mengenai hak mereka perlu ditingkatkan supaya mereka bijak membuat keputusan pembelian dan tidak diperlekeh oleh sesetengah peniaga yang tidak bertanggungjawab ketika musim perayaan. Wartawan Berita Harian, HATIPAH AHMAD, menemu bual Ketua Setiausaha (KSU) Kementerian Perdagangan Dalam Negeri dan Hal Ehwal Pengguna (KPDNHEP) yang baru dilantik September lalu, Datuk Talaat Husain, bagi mendapat pandangan beliau mengenainya.

BERITA HARIAN (BH): Tahniah atas pelantikan Datuk baru-baru ini. Sebagai KSU KPDNHEP yang baru, bagaimana Datuk melihat tanggungjawab ini dan apakah yang ingin diterapkan supaya matlamat kementerian untuk melahirkan pengguna berhemah berhasil?

TALAAT: Terima kasih. Ini adalah tugas baru bagi saya dalam bidang perdagangan dalam negeri dan hal ehwal pengguna. Walaupun diakui tugas sebelum ini berbeza daripada bidang kepenggunaan, saya melihat ia satu cabaran. Justeru, saya banyak membuat kajian dan melihat usaha pemimpin terdahulu di kementerian ini supaya dapat merangka program akan datang.

Kementerian ini sebenarnya masih baru, lebih kurang 14 tahun. Pada mulanya, ia adalah sebahagian daripada Kementerian Perdagangan Antarabangsa dan Industri (Miti), kemudiannya diasingkan menjadi satu kementerian baru. KPDNHEP mempunyai banyak isu yang perlu diberi perhatian dan isunya pula sentiasa berkembang. Apabila mengambil alih, saya melihat bidang perdagangan dalam negeri sudah sedia besar dan mempunyai banyak ruang untuk dikembangkan. Justeru, ia perlu diperbaiki serta diperkukuhkan dengan membawa beberapa idea baru. Pada masa sama, saya berharap untuk mewujudkan suasana kerja yang mesra, sepakat dan berpasukan di kalangan kakitangan.

BH: Apakah idea baru yang Datuk mahu laksanakan?

TALAAT: Saya ingin memperkenalkan satu skim insentif yang menarik kepada peniaga tempatan supaya mereka dapat bersaing dengan syarikat besar dari luar negara dan pada masa sama, mengembangkan sektor perdagangan dalam negeri. Ketika ini, skim sebegini masih belum ada. Saya berasa ia perlu supaya masyarakat perniagaan terdedah kepada persaingan dan bersedia serta mampu untuk memberi perkhidmatan yang sama taraf dengan syarikat besar.

Justeru, kementerian akan memastikan untuk terus membantu peniaga tempatan supaya mereka dapat terus bersaing dengan peniaga luar negara. Jika kita tidak dapat menguasai persaingan dari segi teknologi, mungkin kita boleh memantapkan dari segi kecekapan dan operasi. Oleh itu, selain insentif, ilmu juga penting sebagai modal persaingan yang sihat kepada peniaga.

BH: Bagaimanakah Datuk melihat ilmu kepenggunaan di kalangan masyarakat?

TALAAT: Saya melihat kesedaran terhadap kepenggunaan dan ilmu mengenainya di kalangan masyarakat masih lagi belum mantap, sedangkan ia sangat penting bagi mewujudkan iklim persaingan yang sihat di dalam perniagaan tempatan. Kalau boleh, saya ingin menjadikan masyarakat pengguna di negara ini seperti rakan mereka di luar negara yang mana jika berlaku kenaikan harga tidak munasabah, mereka akan menjalankan tugas dengan mengenakan pelbagai tekanan kepada peniaga.

Tekanan itu ialah mereka akan menggunakan hak sebagai pengguna yang memegang kuasa dari segi pilihan, pembelian dan wang. Ini sekali gus memberi tekanan kepada peniaga untuk mengurangkan harga jika tidak mahu kerugian. Cara ini lebih berkesan kerana kuasa membeli adalah di tangan mereka.

Di Malaysia, jika berlaku kenaikan harga, pengguna akan pergi atau mengadu kepada kerajaan. Kita maklum hal ini kerana tugas menjaga hak pengguna adalah tanggungjawab kerajaan, sedangkan di luar negara, ia menjadi tugas pertubuhan bukan kerajaan (NGO).

BH: Bagaimana Datuk mahu merapatkan diri lebih dekat dengan pengguna?

TALAAT: Cara paling berkesan ialah menerusi strategi teknologi maklumat (IT). Saya melihat sistem ini dapat melicinkan pelaksanaan tugas. Penggunaan IT bukan saja membantu mengemas kini aliran perkembangan industri dan mempercepatkan keputusan, malah dapat merapatkan kementerian dengan pengguna.

Ini boleh dilakukan dengan mewujudkan saluran yang lebih interaktif seperti portal di luar laman web kami. Ketika ini, KPDNHEP mempunyai unit aduan untuk orang ramai membuat aduan, terkini mereka sudah boleh mengadu melalui sistem pesanan ringkas (SMS). Saya bercadang memperluaskan alternatif dengan mewujudkan portal bagi mendapatkan perhubungan yang lebih interaktif sesama pengguna yang mana portal itu bukan milik kerajaan, sebaliknya forum sesama pengguna.

Cara ini dapat mewujudkan suasana lebih mesra, selesa dan terbuka antara pengguna di mana kementerian boleh memberi input tertentu, selebihnya terletak di tangan pengguna untuk saling berkongsi pandangan dan berbincang mengenai kepenggunaan.

Mewujudkan portal di luar laman web rasmi kementerian lebih baik bagi melengkapkan laman web sedia ada. Biasanya orang kurang berminat dengan laman web rasmi dan kurang mengunjunginya berbanding portal forum yang lebih interaktif.

BH: Bagaimana Datuk mahu menangani isu yang masih lagi kurang difahami oleh pengguna seperti harta intelek?

TALAAT: Harta intelek adalah bidang yang masih baru di negara ini. Bagi menanganinya, perkara yang harus diberi tumpuan ialah memperkenalkan konsepnya kepada orang ramai dengan lebih jelas. Masyarakat hanya tahu harta intelek secara umum saja. Jika bertanya mengenai perinciannya, prinsip dan cara untuk mengawal atau mempertahankan harta intelek, masyarakat tidak tahu.

Apabila pengetahuan mengenai akta dan undang-undang harta intelek sudah dapat disebarkan dengan menyeluruh kepada masyarakat, barulah usaha penguatkuasaan ke atasnya dapat dilakukan dengan berkesan kerana orang takut untuk menyalahi peraturannya.

Buat masa ini, ia masih lagi pada peringkat awal ialah kesedaran. Ini perlu diperjelaskan supaya orang ramai sedar dan menghormati harta intelek serta hak yang berkaitan dengannya.

BH: Antara masalah di KPDNHEP ialah kekurangan anggota sedangkan tanggungjawab kementerian besar. Malah, pada peringkat negeri pun, ada pejabat penguat kuasa saja. Bagaimana Datuk hendak menangani isu ini supaya hak pengguna terpelihara?

TALAAT: Kita perlu sedar bahawa kementerian ini masih lagi baru berbanding kementerian lain yang sudah wujud sejak merdeka lagi. Perkembangan sesebuah agensi bergantung juga kepada faktor masa, walaupun semangat untuk melaksanakan tugas memang besar di kalangan anggota kami.

Kita memang memerlukan pertimbangan Pusat bagi mendapatkan lebih ramai anggota dan peruntukan untuk menjalankan tanggungjawab. Walaupun ia tidak boleh dijalankan serta merta, saya yakin usaha memelihara hak pengguna dapat dijalankan dengan berkesan menerusi beberapa pendekatan kementerian.

BH: Apakah pendekatan itu?

TALAAT: Antaranya dengan mengadakan perkongsian tugas dengan NGO dan masyarakat. Contohnya, pada peringkat kebangsaan, kementerian bekerjasama dengan NGO bagi menubuhkan Majlis Hal Ehwal Pengguna di peringkat negeri dan daerah. Menerusi kerjasama ini, kita dapat menggunakan fungsi NGO untuk memantau keadaan dan suasana perdagangan dalam negeri.

Malah, kita ada konsep sukarelawan pemantau harga yang kini sudah ada lebih 15,000 di seluruh negara. Jumlah ini sungguh menggalakkan dan dijangka terus meningkat dari semasa ke semasa.

Mereka berjasa besar terutama ketika musim perayaan atau pada hari biasa jika berlaku kenaikan harga tanpa sebab di pasaran. Mereka pergi ke pasar atau kedai setiap hari untuk memantau harga dan melaporkan kepada kementerian.

BH: Apakah nasihat Datuk kepada pengguna?

TALAAT: Oleh kerana tugas kementerian berkait rapat dengan pengguna, mereka perlu memainkan peranan. Konsep perkongsian tanggungjawab perlu dipraktikkan jika mahu hak mereka terus terpelihara. Pengguna perlu sedar bahawa mereka sebenarnya mempunyai tanggungjawab besar kerana mereka ada kuasa membeli dan hak ke atas wang ringgit dalam mendapatkan barang yang berpadanan dengan nilai duit mereka.

Jika pengguna berasa sesuatu benda yang ingin dibeli mahal, mereka boleh memilih sama ada membelinya atau tidak. Jika masih mahu benda yang sama, mereka terpaksa mengorbankan wang ringgit sedangkan mereka masih ada peluang untuk membeli benda sama yang lebih murah di kedai lain.

Dalam hal ini, kebijaksanaan memilih adalah kunci kepada hak kepenggunaan. Kementerian tidak boleh memaksa peniaga menurunkan harga semata-mata ada pengguna yang berasa harga barang yang dijual mahal.

Masyarakat peniaga juga mempunyai matlamat untuk memaksimumkan keuntungan tetapi pada masa sama, mereka juga bergantung kepada pengguna untuk mengelakkan diri daripada kerugian. Jadi, pengguna perlu menggunakan kebijaksanaan mendapatkan barang murah dan berkualiti. Banyak pilihan yang ada di pasaran, gunakan dengan sebaik-baiknya.

Petronas: NGV Use For Cleaner Environment, Not Due To Higher Oil Prices

General


November 01, 2004 17:51 PM E-mail this news to a friend Printable version of this news


Petronas President and CEO Tan Sri Hassan Marican (left) during an interview with BERNAMA in Kuala Lumpur, Monday.

KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 1 (Bernama) -- Petronas is encouraging the use of Natural Gas for Vehicles (NGV) because it is better for the environment - not because oil prices have gone through the roof.

"If you are going to relate the increase in NGV use to oil prices you are not looking at it in the right perspective," Petronas President and CEO Tan Sri Hassan Marican told reporters Monday.

"We would like to expand NGV for environmental reasons," Hassan stressed.

"If you are talking about NGV substituting gasoline or diesel because of the high price of gasoline and diesel, you have to also understand that NGV is also subsidised," he pointed out.

The subsidy comes from Petronas, he said.

NGV sells for between 56 and 58 sen per litre, he said, which is about half the price of gasoline.

Diesel sells for 83 sen per litre.

Although Hassan would not specify the Petronas subsidy for NGV, the market price for NGV is understood to be between the market price of diesel and the market price of gasoline.

If more vehicles switched to NGV, more gasoline could be exported and could earn more foreign exchange for Malaysia, but he stressed that these are "secondary factors".

The Cabinet Committee to study the impact of the price increase of fuel and petroleum products on the economy had recommended the use of NGV last month.

Transport Minister Datuk Seri Chan Kong Choy said on Oct 21 that the Cabinet Committee on NGV plans to increase the number of public vehicles using NGV by about 10 per cent and more NGV stations would have to be built - with plans for another 200 stations by 2007.

Petronas began a pilot NGV programme in 1986 and set up Petronas NGV in 1995.

Today, about 12,300 vehicles use NGV in Malaysia.

Only 120 of them are private vehicles. The rest are taxis.

There are now 38 NGV stations across the peninsula, with 10 more under construction.

Vehicles contribute about 79 per cent of the air pollution in the country.

NGV is the cleanest burning fuel and significantly reduces the levels of carbon monoxide, hydrocarbon and nitrogen oxide.

"If we can get buses and (government) fleet vehicles to run on NGV, we would have cleaner air, especially in the Klang Valley," Hassan predicted, noting that Petronas had also pioneered the use of unleaded petroleum in the country.

He pointed out that when India introduced legislation making it compulsory for public transport to switch to NGV, the air quality improved.

Petronas has developed limousine taxis using NGV with a French company and owns some intellectual property rights for this, Hassan added.

In addition to their use in Malaysia, the NGV limousine taxis are being tested in Bangkok via the Petroleum Authority of Thailand (PTT) and in Manila via the Philippines National Oil Corporation (PNOC).

-- BERNAMA

Monday, November 01, 2004

‘Private service’ at government hospitals

The Star Online > News > Opinion

Sunday October 31, 2004
The full payment service, to be introduced next year in first class wards at selected Government hospitals, will need to be properly implemented in order for it to attain its objectives. WONG LI ZA reports.

DR K. Dylan (not his real name) who is in his sixth year of service with a Government hospital in Selangor readily admitted that he has often thought about moving to private practice.

“It is natural for people to look for greener pastures,” said the 36-year-old.

Dr Arumugam: ‘Doctors pushing for new scheme for some time now’
The recently announced move by the Health Ministry to implement full payment service at first class wards in certain Government hospitals which, among other reasons, was aimed at encouraging doctors to stay on, should therefore have been good news.

However, Dr Dylan has his reservations.

“What kind of increase (in salary) are we talking about so that doctors will still feel compelled to stay? And will it match that in the private sector in time to come?” he queried.

According to Dr Dylan, a specialist in the government sector earns between RM7,000 and RM7,500 while in the private sector, he or she can earn between RM10,000 and RM15,000.

“Private hospitals function because of medical insurance and the faster service they can provide. Government hospitals function because of government subsidies and taxpayers' money,” he said.

The full payment service, to be implemented next year beginning with Selayang and Putrajaya Hospitals, would see patients in first-class wards being able to choose the doctors and specialists to treat them, as is the practice in private hospitals.

These patients would be paying full doctors' fees according to the fee schedule drawn by the Malaysian Medical Association.

The Cabinet has also agreed to allow public sector doctors to do locum in government hospitals and clinics.

The full payment plan aims to provide services on par with that of private hospitals, improve overall efficiency and services, and increase competition in the healthcare industry.

It is also expected to increase Government medical services revenue.

The Ministry hopes to target those with insurance coverage and patients whose medical expenses are borne by their employers with this service.

It also assured that there would be no special attention for patients in terms of receiving faster surgery or treatment just because they were paying in full, and surgery or treatment given will be based on the medical condition of patients.

Dr Dylan admitted that the plan was a good move by the Government to help increase doctors' salary, Government revenue and to meet the people's need.

“The Government should sustain the needs of the people and doctors should work to support that. Whatever said and done, a doctor is supposed to save lives, whether you’re paid or not, but most of us will not have that service attitude,” he said.

Muhammad Sha’ani: ‘Public needs more information on system’
The Federation of Malaysian Consumers Associations (Fomca) secretary-general Muhammad Sha’ani Abdullah raised some points about the potential success of the full payment service, however.

“Are there guidelines in place on its implementation?” he queried, saying that one problem in public medical service was doctors did not stay long because of the relatively low and fixed pay structure.

“With this new service, there should be procedures and guidelines on how to compensate doctors,” he said.

Malaysian Medical Association president Datuk Dr N. Arumugam said Government doctors have been pushing for the new scheme for some time.

“This new move targets doctors who are still unsure about whether they want to stay or leave public service,” he said.

Under this scheme, the Government might propose two different sessions a day in which doctors would be serving – one treating regular patients and the other, full paying patients, he explained.

“Supplementary income (from full-paying sessions) may help these doctors stay back,” said Dr Arumugam.

Many doctors enjoyed working in Government hospitals due to the variety of cases and job fulfilment but at the end of the day, the monetary issue factored in, for example paying for children's education, he added.

For patients, medical treatment is a personal thing and they may prefer and request treatment from certain doctors, which was presently not allowed in Government hospitals, he said.

With the new system, said Dr Arumugam, patients would be able to choose a better ward and the doctor of their choice while paying a lower price compared to that of private hospitals.

But, he said, there was one problem with the new move: first- and second-class wards in Government hospitals were currently already full most of the time. (There are over 1,680 beds in first-class wards in the country at present.)

“But the Government will try it out anyway, and may later build a private wing (if the response is good),” he said.

Malaysian Employers Federation executive director Shamsuddin Bardan said the Health Ministry should look at the availability of beds before fully implementing the system so that patients would not be pushed to other wards even though they were paying the full amount.

“Otherwise, promises would remain as that,” said Shamsuddin.

Muhammad Sha'ani also said the Ministry needed to stick to its promise that full-paying patients would not be given priority in the waiting list for surgery and treatment just because they paid in full.

“Government hospitals have to improve the overall waiting period of getting treatment so that there is no preferential treatment for anyone,” he stressed.

“And if the Government is seriously looking for extra revenue, then yes, it should give better service to paying patients to get the market,” he said, adding that the new service could lead to private hospitals lowering their fees to compete with Government hospitals.

Shamsuddin said private sector employees generally preferred private hospital services because of their less favourable experience with Government hospitals.

Among the grouses MEF received from employers were long waiting periods and that emergency cases were not immediately treated, he said.

“If we switch to Government hospitals, we might have a lot of objections due to the stigma already attached to Government service,” said Shamsuddin.

“But in the event that the full payment system is implemented and service is equivalent, if not better, than the private sector, then the perception may change, but that has yet to be proven,” he said.

On a positive note, Shamsuddin said it was a known fact that Government hospitals always have good equipment and facilities.

“And if charges are less than in private hospitals, it could attract private sector employers to come in (and use the new service),” said Shamsuddin.

Muhammad Sha'ani said the new move was another option to creating a separate, private wing in Government hospitals.

“I presume that this is to avoid complete privatisation of health services, which is something Fomca is against.”

Both Muhammad Sha'ani and Dr Arumugam concurred that the new scheme would need a lot of administration and paper work to make it work.

“People are also still sceptical. The Health Ministry has to have more awareness and education programmes about this (service). And the public needs more information about the whole system and how it works so that they will not misjudge it,” said Muhammad Sha'ani.


Links